
I have heard the wealthy talk about how hard they worked for their wealth and how much of an individual accomplishment it is for them. I even read an opinion article last winter in the Aspen Times about how the minimum wage should not be raised because the only people who earned minimum wage were high school students who were supported by their parents and the money was simply spending money. The opinion piece went on to talk about how if a person was earning minimum wage who wasn't a high school student, it was their own fault because anyone with ambition who worked hard and had some education could earn more than minimum wage.
That opinion piece infuriated me.
As Elizabeth Warren so eloquently stated this week: "There is nobody in this country who got rich on his own. Nobody. You built a factory out there-- good for you. But I want to be clear. You moved your goods to market on the roads the rest of us paid for. You hired workers the rest of us paid to educate. You were safe in your factory because of police forces that the rest of us paid for. You didn't have to worry that marauding bands would come and seize everything at your factory... Now look. You built a factory and it turned into something terrific or a great idea-- God bless! Keep a big hunk of it. But part of the underlying social contract is you take a hunk of that and pay forward for the next kid who comes along."
When I was growing up, my mother was waitress. I started working by picking blueberries in the summer for 75 cents a bucket. I could pick 6 buckets in a day. The money I earned during blueberry season was how I bought school clothes. My blue jeans came from a warehouse outlet and anything else came from K-mart or was a gift from grandma. When I was in seventh grade I began working at my uncle's restaurant washing dishes. I made $2 an hour. My mother's house was bought by paying my uncle who took out the loan because as a divorcee she couldn't get a mortgage. My mother always drove used cars. We had a Valiant at one point that had been a delivery car and had a hole in the roof where a sign had been bolted on. You could stick a finger through it to the outside air. Typically in our house we had canned soup, some eggs, mayonnaise, peanut butter, and white bread. Occasionally my mother would make soup or applesauce. The cupboards were often bare. My mother went to college for music and math. When I was in high school she went to a skilled training center and learned to become a payroll clerk. That skilled training center was subsidized by the government. She couldn't have gone on to become a payroll clerk without that training.
When I went to the University of Michigan for my bachelors degree in English language and literature, the entire cost of my undergraduate education was paid for by grants, scholarships, and a small number of national direct student loans that were government subsidized and at the rate of 2%. I had one year where my paperwork was lost for several months and I worked a patchwork of hours in 3 jobs to get by. But I doubt I could have gotten my undergraduate degree without financial aid and I am grateful I was able to get that degree. I now have a masters degree in education that I worked hard to get with a combination of multiple jobs and financial aid. Today most people that I know working towards a bachelors degree who don't have their tuition paid for by their parents are working a job and going part time. Little aid outside of loans is available and the cost of a college education is astronomical.
There is a myth that poor people are poor simply because they made bad choices. But right now the number of people in poverty is increasing and the number of unemployed is staggeringly high and has been. Did all these people make bad choices? I don't think so.
At the same time, the ultra-wealthy of this country are getting wealthier with a little help from a tax structure that benefits them the most. It isn't class warfare to ask them to help pay a larger percentage of taxes-- taxes that go for things like roads, fire departments, police, teachers to educate future employees, etc. Why should they be the only ones getting subsidized? Perhaps we should have a jobs plan that includes hiring unemployed architects, teachers, engineers, IT specialists and others to refurbish the United States infrastructure? New public works, a better grid system with more alternative energy, new water treatment centers, retraining centers, the clean-up of toxic sites-- all of this could be worked on. Imagine if we had used the $860 billion dollars per year going to the war in Iraq for this. Imagine if we had used the money from the bailout of the financial industry for this.
I would suggest to anyone who says that a person should pull themselves up by their "bootstraps" that they actually walk a mile in the boots of that person-- a poor person before they judge. What would you do to get by paycheck to paycheck or aid check to aid check? Would you turn the heat down to 50 degrees fahrenheit and hope the pipes didn't freeze? Would you turn down medical insurance because the premium through your employer would cost a third of your take home pay? Would you go and stand in line for food at the community food pantry? Could you come up with enough creative recipes to use 20 lbs. of sweet potatoes before they went bad? Do you know what to do with dried beans and several cans of cream style corn? What job would you be willing to take to make ends meet? Could you buy enough food to feed yourself and a family on $50 per week? What would you buy? Where would you live?
Jenny Nicholson who works with Urban Ministries created a game called "Spent" to raise money for the group. She grew up poor. Al Lewis writing for "Market Watch" in article titled "Poverty Isn't Just a Game" quoted her as saying about her upbringing “My mom always went through the grocery store with a calculator, We didn’t have a checking account. She had $50 in her pocket, and if the food was $51 we were screwed. Sometimes my mom wouldn’t calculate the tax right and … we’d have to decide what we were going to put back.” Her mother couldn't afford a monthly gas bill so they went without heat and hot water. Her mother died at 46 from a heart attack because she couldn't afford health care and had been denied medicaid coverage.
I would encourage anyone to play the game "Spent" and donate to Urban Ministries here is the link: http://playspent.org/
I did pretty well. I got through the month even though I lost my job in the game and the rent was due the next day, but I grew up poor and have worked in retail or been an early childhood teacher most of my adult life. I have had some practice making decisions that will allow me to go from paycheck to paycheck. See how you do.






